(FASCISM and PHILOSOPHY – continued)
Kita. He was a right-wing socialist who appealed to extremists in the military. He advocated a coup in support of the emperor who had him executed.
Nakano. He was a liberal legislator known for his eloquence. Then he saw fascism as a way to elevate Japan.
Kita Ikki (surname first) began his political philosophy with an anti-capitalism that was common to agricultural people – and to militarists with family backgrounds that were agricultural. He audited lectures at Waseda University in Tokyo, and while a student was attracted to socialism. It was not the socialism of Karl Marx, who believed in worker power. Kita's socialism, outlined in his book The Theory of Japan's National Polity and Pure Socialism, published in 1906 when he was 23, described Marxism and a working class-oriented socialism as outdated. He wanted a socialism from above.
Kita's next book, published a decade later, was titled An Outline Plan for the Reorganization of Japan. In it he added to the theme in his first book by advocating a united Japan pursuing a free Asia, an Asia united in opposition to Western authority and influence. He advocated a military coup d'état that would create a regime in Japan based on rule by the Emperor. The contradictory nature of this escaped him. Why a ruling emperor could not command his own military to his support without help from a clique of dissatisfied officers he did not say.
The enhanced rule of the Emperor in Kita's estimation should include a suspended constitution and a radically reorganized parliament free of influences that he thought detrimental to his new Japan.
Kita's work influenced some in the Japanese military, perhaps moved by his having included them as instruments in creating an improved Japan. It was a childlike political naivety, from someone who would be described as a political philosopher.
A faction within the military attempted a coup in February 1936. It claimed to be in support of the emperor. An enraged Hirohito would have none of it. He called the coup leaders criminals. Fifteen of the coup leaders were executed by firing squad. No dates were given for the executions, and no ashes were returned to their relatives. Kita was among those arrested and executed.
A biography of Nakano Seigo by Leslie R. Oates, with the title Populist Nationalism in Pre-war Japan, points to what Fascism was at least in part: populist nationalism. The other ingredients can be said to be support for an imperialist foreign policy and enforced control over ideas – such as Plato advocated in his Utopia. Nakano (surname first) Seigo supported all of these.
Nakano was a graduate of Japan's prestigious Waseda University, a successful journalist, and in 1920 at the age of 34, he was elected as a member of Japan's House of Representatives. He began his political career as a liberal. He was viewed as having eloquence, and he continually won re-election.
Fascist ideas were spreading, and Nakano bought into it. He was influenced by the writings of Kita Ikki and wanted a rebirth for Japan – a super and more glorious Japan among other ideas accompanied by what was imagined to be the Samurai ethic. He held to a romantic view of the Samurai and admired Saigo Takamori, the so-called "last true samurai" who led the great revolt against Meiji authority and Japan's standing army. The Meiji government abolished feudal titles, ranks and privileges, including Samurai privileges, like abusing common people whenever they pleased. From the Meiji government's perspective Saigo Takamori was a criminal. Nakano believed in an intense patriotism for Japan and yet clung to the image of rebellion and the Samurai Saigo Takamori as a hero. It was a common fascistic attitude of wanting to assert themselves to replace the status quo with their own power.
Nakano's patriotism had a totalitarian element. He favored unified adherence to ideas imposed by an elite for the sake of order. He opposed the degree of democracy that Japan had, believing that leaving common people to set standards leads to an abandonment of principles. He believed as had Plato that he and those who agree with him, a philosophical elite, had a monopoly on the knowledge as to what is best for society. Democracy, Nakano said, was "the precise cause of contemporary decadence."
Nakano was opposed to an "individualism that shows no concern for others." Somewhat contrary to his belief in elitist (anti-democratic) politics, he favored an organic unification of citizens "sharing common ideals and a common way of feeling." And rather than people with money deciding what should be done economically, he favored a state run economy – which put him at odds with the thinking of Japan's more traditional conservatives. As elsewhere, there was in Japan some merger between wealthy business families and the nobility. Some industrialists belonged to old Samurai families that had made the shift from military prowess to commerce. Japan's elite liked the idea of cooperation between business, government and labor that was taking place in Mussolini's Italy and in Hitler's Germany. [note] The extensive state control that Nakano advocated would not have the support needed to become government policy. But he opposed taking power in a coup as Kita had tried to do. His strategy for success was modeled after the successes of Mussolini and Hitler – a lesson Hitler had learned after his failed coup in 1923.
In 1936, Nakano formed his own political party, the Tohokai party. The Tohokai wore black shirts with armbands bearing the Japanese character for 'East', and they held party held mass rallies. At its peak, in 1937, it held 11 seats in Japan's parliament – the Diet.
In 1940 he and his party ran afoul from a competing totalitarian force: the government of General Hideki Tojo, who wanted a single party state, was super-nationalist and more adamantly expansionist than Nakano.
In October 1943, Nakano was arrested on charges of plotting to overthrow the Tojo regime, and he committed suicide under mysterious circumstances soon after being released. In October 1940 his party was merged into the government's Imperial Rule Assistance Association. In 1942, Nakano violated his principle of organic whole and patriotic devotion to authority and broke away from the government party. He was a victim of the kind of rule that he advocated. In October 1943, he was arrested and charged with plotting to overthrow the government. He was released and soon after committed suicide.
Copyright © 2009-2011 by Frank E. Smitha. All rights reserved.