CANADA and the UNITED STATES, 1814-46

Canada and the United States, 1814-46

British North America vis-à-vis the United States

North of the United States was British North America, divided into colonies as had been the United States. There was Newfoundland, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Lower Canada, (Quebec) and Upper Canada (Ontario) - which together had about one-eighteenth the population of the United States.

Following the War of 1812 , tensions remained between the United States and Britain. A naval arms race developed in the Great Lakes region, and incidents occurred on the lakes as the British exercised what they believed was their right to search U.S. ships. In 1817 the U.S. War Department sent two expeditions to the south shore of Lake Superior to remove British flags and to establish U.S. influence -- in what was essentially Indian country. But there was to be no war. The War of 1812 was that last of what could be called a war that involved the border between the United States and its northern neighbor.

Hostility toward Britain remained among those in the United States who chose to remember recent conflicts, and Britain's upper classes remained hostile toward the United States. But the British and the United States would be able to resolve their conflicts. Britain accepted the revolution that transformed its colonies into the United States. The U.S. and Britain were two liberal powers, one a constitutional monarchy, the other a republic. There were no dynastic rivalries or kings competing for land. Expansion westward was possible without expanding against each other. Moreover, wealthy men in shipping and commerce in the United States disliked the idea of war because they knew that it would shut down commerce, and they disliked the idea of losing ships to the British.

The United States had high tariffs against British imports, erected in 1816, inspired in part by the desire to deprive Britain of one of its largest export markets as well as to protect American manufacturers and farmers from foreign competition. But enough political leaders in the U.S. saw it in their nation's interest to establish accords with Britain that, in 1818, the U.S. and Britain produced the Rush-Bagot Agreement for disarmament on the Great Lakes. Each power was to have no more than four warships on the Great Lakes, none of which was to exceed 100 tons.

In 1820, Methodist ministers who had migrated to Canada (there were almost 6,000 Methodists in Upper Canada) tried to get help from the U.S. to rid them of competition from Wesleyan ministers from Britain -- the British Wesleyans numbering around 750. [note] But the U.S. government was not interested in intervening in this conflict.

please continue

to navigation links at the top